Issues

Vegan: Yes or No?

Which diet causes the least suffering.

The Law of the Earth says you may eat animals if you need to, but you have to try not to, and you must choose the sources that involve the least suffering. That raises an obvious question: which diet actually causes the least suffering? Most people assume the answer is "plants, obviously." It isn't that simple.

What one cow gives

A 1,300-pound steer yields about 639 pounds of edible beef once bone, fat, and trim are removed (Iowa Beef Industry Council). In Australia, a grass-fed animal yields on average about 45 kilograms (about 100 pounds) of protein (Archer, The Conversation).

What the same protein takes in plants

Using the same article's wheat figures (1.4 tonnes per hectare, 13% usable protein), 45 kilograms of protein takes about 350 kilograms (about 760 pounds) of wheat, grown on about a quarter hectare (about 0.6 acres). (Our arithmetic, from the figures above.)

Soy and corn are richer: about 1,000 kilograms of protein per hectare. Grass-fed beef needs about 10 hectares of pasture to produce the same amount (Lamey, summarizing Matheny 2003). So one cow's worth of protein takes roughly a twentieth of a hectare of soy and corn, or almost half a hectare of pasture. (Our arithmetic, from the figures above.)

How many creatures die

Crops. Plowing, harvest, and poison kill field animals, mostly mice. The best-known estimate is about 15 field animals per hectare per year for crops, and about 7.5 for pasture (Davis 2003). That estimate rests on only two studies, and later work found that most of the mouse deaths came from predators after harvest, not from the machines (review of Lamey, Duty and the Beast).

Per acre, pasture wins. Per meal, it usually loses. Because a hectare of crops feeds far more people, the count flips once you measure by food instead of by land. Correcting Davis's math, Matheny found that to supply an adult's 20 kilograms of protein a year, a vegan diet kills about 0.3 wild animals, and Davis's grass-fed omnivore diet about 1.5 (Matheny 2003).

Applied to one cow's worth of protein, using Davis's own rates (our arithmetic):

Source of 45 kg proteinLandField deathsPlus
Soy and cornabout 0.05 haunder 1
Wheatabout 0.25 haabout 4
Grass-fed beefabout 0.45 haabout 3the cow

The Australian claim. A widely read 2011 article argued that wheat kills at least 25 times more animals per kilogram of protein than rangeland beef, because of mouse poisoning during plagues (Archer). A 2018 paper found it had overcounted: the corrected figure is about 1.27 animals per 100 kilograms of wheat protein, against 55 claimed, and grazing land's own mouse deaths had been left out (editor's note on the same article).

Insects. No one has a reliable count. Pesticides kill insects in enormous numbers wherever crops are sprayed, including crops grown to feed livestock.

What it adds up to

  • On good cropland, plants usually cost fewer lives per unit of food, by most published counts.
  • The case for meat is strongest on land that can't grow crops (dry rangeland, hills, rocky ground). There the choice isn't between a cow and a wheat field. It's between a cow and no food at all.
  • Feedlot meat is the worst of both. The animal eats crops too, roughly two to ten kilos of plants for every kilo of animal (Archer), so it carries the crop deaths and the slaughter.
  • How food is raised matters as much as what it is. A permaculture food forest with no plowing kills far fewer field animals than a sprayed monocrop. Grass-fed beef from land that can't be farmed is not the same as feedlot beef.

That's why the Law doesn't pick a diet for anyone. It asks each person to keep listening to the evidence, and to choose the sources that involve the least suffering.