Rationality

Summarize First

Show you understand before you refute.

Before rebutting an argument, the responder plays a short version of it back, and the other party confirms that's what they meant.

Why

You can't show the flaw in an argument you don't understand. Logically, you can't refute what you haven't grasped. So before even attempting a rebuttal, you show that you've understood it: "So you're saying A, which leads to B, which means C. Is that right?"

What It Prevents

It stops people from knocking down a version of the argument nobody made. It stops arguments from sliding past each other. And it often settles things on its own: once someone's argument is played back accurately, the two sides sometimes find they never disagreed.

Then Point to the Flaw

Once the summary is confirmed, the rebuttal can be precise: "Your A leads to B, and B leads to C, but C doesn't lead to D." See Rebuttals.

This page comes from the author's Rules of Debate.