Rationality

Provisional Acceptance

Accepting an argument for now.

If you can't find a flaw in an argument, you must accept it, either absolutely or provisionally.

Absolutely or Provisionally

Accepting absolutely means saying, "Yes, that's true." Accepting provisionally means saying, "I'm not sure yet. I haven't found a flaw, but I haven't had time to think it through. For now, I accept it so we can move forward. I reserve the right to come back if I find one."

It Still Carries Weight

Either way, an accepted argument carries its full weight on the chart. If it supports another argument, that argument counts as supported. If it weighs against another, that one counts as undermined. This is what the Law means when it says an unanswered argument still stands.

Coming Back

Reserving the right to return is not a way to stall. If you come back, you come back with a specific flaw, charted like any other rebuttal.

This page comes from the author's Rules of Debate.