A rebuttal is an answer that attacks an argument. There are only three kinds.
- Refutation: a new claim which, if true, makes the other untrue. A claim of fact is refuted by a proven fact that negates it, along with a showing of how it negates it.
- Disputed connection: showing that a support, though perhaps true, doesn't actually support what it's meant to. "Yes, A is true, but A doesn't lead to B."
- Named fallacy: pointing out a move that proves nothing, like the ones on the list "What Does Not Equal Correct" on the Rationality page. Loud does not equal correct. Popular does not equal correct. Ending a debate is not winning it.
What Is Not a Rebuttal
A "better" argument for the other side is not a rebuttal. Neither is calling an argument "crap," or "not an argument," or changing the subject. An argument of logic falls only when its flaw is identified, never by an unrelated argument, however emotionally compelling.
A Rebuttal Must Survive Too
A refutation is itself an argument, and must withstand the same scrutiny it brings. If a debunking is debunked, it no longer debunks anything.
Before rebutting, play the argument back first. See Summarize First.