Rationality

The Failsafe

When reason can't decide, liberty wins.

What happens when an arbitration can't be settled? A fact can't be established with the evidence available, or both sides have argued to the bottom and the question is still open.

The Rule

Then the claim has not been proven. Since the Burden of Proof is always on the one who would use force, no force may be used.

Why This Is the Failsafe

Every system of justice has to decide what happens when it can't tell. Most quietly side with power. The Law of the Earth sides with the person being left alone. No one can be detained on a hunch, a suspicion, or a stalemate.

This isn't a new rule so much as what follows from two old ones: the burden of proof on the upholder, and no force without rational justification. Both are set out on Legitimate Force.