The Law of the Earth

Title 6: Power

Weapons, war, and deterrence.

The Storybook of the Law

Contents of this chapter
  1. Power
  2. War
  3. Weapons
  4. Deterrence
  5. Disarmament
  6. Development
  7. Knowledge and Tools

Title 6: Power

Power

Power is the capacity to compel.
It is lawful only in defense of the lawful.

What a person may do in defense,
a people may do in defense,
and nothing more.

189

Commentary

POWER

Normally you can't kill people. In a war, you can, because if you don't kill them, they'll kill you. That is the oldest exception in law, and the most abused. This Title draws its edges.

It adds no new right. It takes the right of defense from Legitimate Force and follows it up in scale, from one person to a village to a nation. Whatever is lawful for one defender is lawful for many, and whatever is unlawful for one is unlawful for many. A crowd, an army, or a government gains no permission that a single person lacks.

190

Title 6: Power

War

War does not suspend the Law.
In war, as in peace,
force is lawful only to stop a harm
that is happening, or about to happen,
only against those committing it,
and only in proportion.

The innocent are never a target.
No order makes an unlawful act of war lawful.

191

Commentary

WAR

Every war in history has been called defensive by the side that started it. So the Law doesn't ask what a war is called. It asks the same three questions it asks of any use of force: is the harm real and imminent, is the force aimed at those committing it, and is it in proportion. These are the conditions that philosophers of just war have long agreed are truly necessary: necessity and proportionality.

A soldier who kills an attacker in the middle of an attack is defending. A soldier who bombs a market is not, no matter what flag is flying overhead. And "I was ordered to" was never an excuse, as Upholdment already says.

192

Title 6: Power

Weapons

A weapon is anything made to harm.
It is discriminate
if it can be aimed at one aggressor alone,
and indiscriminate if it cannot.
Weapons share a class
when they harm by the same means.

The Measure of a Weapon

A weapon is lawful to hold
in proportion to the threats it answers.
Any person may hold a discriminate weapon
sized to the threats of daily life,
for hunting or defense.
Beyond that, a weapon has no lawful purpose
but to answer another weapon.

193

Commentary

WEAPONS

A rifle can stop one attacker. A grenade can't tell the attacker from the child standing next to him. That is the difference between a discriminate weapon and an indiscriminate one, and it's the line the Law cares about most.

The measure is proportion. A knife, a bow, a rifle, a handgun: these answer the threats of ordinary life, from a wolf to a home invader, and anyone may hold them. A machine gun or a grenade answers no threat of ordinary life. You can't hunt with one. You can't defend your home with one without endangering your neighbors. Such weapons have only one lawful purpose: to answer the same weapons in someone else's hands.

A "class" is a means of harm: fission, nerve agents, engineered disease. Two bombs of different sizes are the same class. A bomb and a plague are not. The distinction matters for the section on Development.

194

Title 6: Power

Deterrence

Weapons that should not exist
may still be held,
where others already hold them,
for one purpose only:
to deter their use.

Conditions of a Deterrent

1. Matched – no greater than the threat it answers;
2. Declared – made known to those it deters,
with the promise never to use it first;
3. Temporary – held only as long as
the threat that justifies it.

A deterrent may answer an attack,
but never begin one.
Whoever uses it
answers for every innocent it harms.

195

Commentary

DETERRENCE

Nuclear weapons should be illegal. But if only one country gets rid of them, it becomes a sitting duck for whoever still has them. The same goes for grenades and machine guns. They should all be illegal, except for the fact that other people already have them.

Game theorists call this the security dilemma. Whoever arms for defense makes everyone else less safe, so they arm too, and the spiral climbs. Laying down your arms alone doesn't stop it. It only makes you the easiest target. So the Law allows the exception, and fences it in.

A deterrent has to be matched, because a larger one is no longer a deterrent, but a threat. It has to be declared, because a hidden deterrent deters no one, and because the other side needs to know it is safe so long as it holds back. A threat with no such promise gives the other side no reason to hold back at all. And it has to be temporary, because the reason for holding it is borrowed from someone else's weapon, and ends when that weapon does.

There is a hard truth in this section. A deterrent works by threatening something terrible, and if the threat is ever carried out, the terrible thing happens. The Law doesn't pretend otherwise. It allows the weapon to be held, and holds whoever uses it to account for every innocent it harms. The only real safety is in the next section.

196

Title 6: Power

Disarmament

Every holder of a deterrent
is bound to offer mutual disarmament,
and to accept any offer that can be verified.

Disarmament proceeds step for step:
each side lays down its weapons
as the other does,
each verifying the other.

Whoever refuses verification
may be presumed armed.

197

Commentary

DISARMAMENT

The way out of the dilemma is the way in, reversed. One side lays down a little, the other does the same, each checks that the other did it, and the next step follows. Neither ever has to trust the other blindly. In 1987, the United States and the Soviet Union destroyed an entire class of nuclear missiles this way, with inspectors from each side on the ground in the other. "Trust, but verify."

The duty to offer is what keeps the exception honest. A deterrent that is never offered for disarmament isn't a deterrent. It's an arsenal. And whoever won't let the other side look has given them every reason to assume the worst.

198

Title 6: Power

Development

Acquiring and Developing

To acquire a weapon that already exists,
in order to deter it,
is lawful under the conditions of Deterrence.
To improve a weapon within its class
is lawful only to keep pace,
never to get ahead.
To develop a new class of weapon
is unlawful, everywhere, always.

The First Foray

Whoever invents a new class of weapon
arms every enemy who copies it.
"Someone else would have built it first"
is no justification.
It is the argument of every arms race.

Defense against a feared weapon
may be studied and built.
The weapon itself may not.

199

Commentary

DEVELOPMENT

Acquiring a weapon, improving one, and inventing one are three different acts, and the Law treats them differently.

Acquiring an existing weapon to deter it changes nothing in the balance of the world. The weapon was already there. Improving a weapon within its class may be needed to keep a deterrent matched, but the moment it seeks an advantage, it starts the spiral climbing again.

Inventing a new class is the hardest act to justify of all. Before it, the danger did not exist. After it, it exists forever, because knowledge can't be uninvented, and every rival who copies the design now holds it too. The first nation to build an atomic bomb did not stay the only one for long.

The usual defense is "If we don't, they will." But that is what both sides always say, and it is exactly how the new weapon comes into the world. The Law cuts the argument off at the root. A shield against a feared weapon may be built. The weapon itself may not, and building it in order to study the shield doesn't count.

If someone else does build one, they are breaking the Law, and they may be upheld against like anyone else: through arbitration first, and the Five Degrees after.

200

Title 6: Power

Knowledge and Tools

Knowledge is not a weapon.
A tool not made to harm
is not a weapon,
even where it could be made into one.

201

Commentary

KNOWLEDGE AND TOOLS

Almost anything can be made into a weapon: chemistry, rocketry, a kitchen knife. If the Law treated every dangerous capability as a weapon, it would end up regulating knowledge itself. So this Title stops at the weapon: the thing made to harm.

The deeper question, how humanity should relate to the technology it creates, is bigger than weapons. It belongs to a Title of its own.

202

← Title 5: GraceTitle 6: Power