Every arbitration has two sides.
The Claimant
The claimant makes the claim: usually, that someone is breaking the Law. Most often the claimant is the person who wants to uphold the Law against someone, and so the claimant carries the Burden of Proof. The claimant leads Phase 1, presenting every argument for the claim.
The Defendant
The defendant disputes the claim. The defendant never has to prove their own innocence. But they do have the burden of listening: they must let the claimant make the case, and follow the claimant's steps in Phase 1. Following is not agreeing. The defendant leads Phase 2, testing each of the claimant's arguments and offering counter-arguments.
Others Present
Upholding arbitration is open to everyone present. Someone with no stake in the outcome may keep the chart if the parties don't trust each other. See The Rational Flow Chart.