Sometimes the parties simply disagree about whether an argument has been refuted. Neither will budge. The answer is to go down.
The Disagreement Becomes a Claim
The disagreement itself becomes a new claim, on its own sheet, tested by the same rules. If that one deadlocks, go down again. Every argument can be broken into smaller ones, because argument has a fractal shape.
Where It Ends
Keep going down until you reach one of two things.
- A question of fact. Settle it with evidence: observation, measurement, records, witnesses. A claim of fact falls to a proven fact that negates it.
- A question of logic. Settle it by showing exactly where the step breaks, or by conceding that it holds.
If It Still Won't Settle
Some facts can't be established with the evidence at hand. When that happens, the claim hasn't been proven. See The Failsafe.