Every term in bold below has its own page. If a step uses a word you don't know, follow the link.
Opening
- Call it. Anyone about to uphold the Law by force, or anyone it would be used against, may say "I call for arbitration." All activity stops until it concludes. In an emergency, act first and arbitrate as soon as it is safe. See Arbitration.
- Name the parties. The claimant says the Law is being broken. The defendant disputes it. See The Parties and Burden of Proof.
- State the claim. The claimant states it in one sentence, and both parties agree on the wording before starting. Agreeing on the wording is not agreeing that it's true.
- Set up the chart. Memory or paper; either party may demand paper. Decide who keeps it. See The Rational Flow Chart.
Phase 1: The Claimant Leads
- The claimant presents every supporting argument, and each is charted under the claim. The defendant follows the course the claimant sets, and may be placed on The Hot Seat. No one interrupts. The defendant has no burden of proof, but does have the burden of listening.
Phase 2: The Defendant Leads
- The defendant takes the claimant's supports one at a time, and may question each one, rebut it, or concede it. See Rebuttals.
- Before rebutting anything, the responder plays a short version of it back, and the other party confirms it. See Summarize First.
- A party who can't find a flaw yet may accept an argument for now, and come back to it later. See Provisional Acceptance.
- The defendant presents any counter-arguments of their own, which are charted too.
Phase 3: Resolution
- The parties alternate, working through every open item on the chart. Every reply must be one of The Five Rational Responses. Answer the question you're asked, keep answers short, and meet the other party at their argument instead of restarting your own case.
- If the parties disagree about whether something has been refuted, the disagreement becomes a claim of its own. See When Stuck, Go Down.
- When an argument falls, it is crossed out, and anything left with no standing support falls with it, all the way up the chart.
- New arguments may be added at any phase. The current phase then resumes.
Conclusion
- The arbitration ends only when no unresolved arguments remain on either side.
- If the claim stands, upholding may proceed, through the Five Degrees of Title 4: Upholdment, and only in proportion. If the claim falls, no force may be used.
- If a question can't be settled with the evidence available, no force may be used. See The Failsafe.
- An arbitration may be put off only to a named time and place. See Postponing.
- A party who repeatedly and impenitently breaks the rules of conduct loses. See Decorum and Forfeit.
- The chart and the outcome are kept. See The Record.
- Any party may appeal. See Appeals: The Wider Circle.