Rationality

Arbitration

A full, logical evaluation of a claim.

Arbitration is what reasoning looks like when the stakes are real. It is how two people who disagree about whether the Law is being broken settle the question without fists, without weapons, and without deferring to whoever has more power.

Whenever Law is being applied,
any party may demand arbitration,
and the other party must engage.

When It Happens

Arbitration is held immediately, wherever the Law is about to be upheld by force. All activity stops until it concludes, and it is open to everyone present. The only exception is an emergency, where harm is about to happen before anyone could finish reasoning. Even then, arbitration must follow as soon as it is safe.

Questions about how the Law applies, with no force at stake, may be brought before a wider circle. See Appeals: The Wider Circle.

Who May Arbitrate

Anyone, provided they can keep up a rational conversation and respect the protocols. No license, office, or title is required.

The Four Principles

  1. Freedom of Speech: each party may speak fully, until finished, without interruption.
  2. Open-Mindedness: any idea may be presented, no matter how "crazy" it sounds, except ideas already presented.
  3. Reason: every argument must be evaluated rationally, and pursued to its conclusion, either proven or disproven.
  4. The Golden Rule: "Treat others as you would wish to be treated" is the standard for moral arguments.

The whole procedure is on Arbitration, Step by Step.