The Law of the Earth
Title 3: Ecology
A planet is a host. A civilization is a guest.
The Storybook of the Law
Contents of this chapter
- The Planet Is an Organism
- The Prime Directive
- Human Survival Necessity
- The Land Council
- The Land Council Protocol
- The Vote
- Soft Rules
- Hard Rules
- Hard Rules, continued
- Land Rights
- Presence and Foraging
- Hunting and Stewardship
- Agriculture
- Territorialization
- Construction
- Transportation
- Natural Resources
- Waste and Restoration
Title 3: Ecology
The Planet Is an Organism
The planet is an organism.
Like any organism,
it is self-regulating,
and able to heal itself.
But resilience is not invincibility.
There are parameters and conditions
necessary for its survival and stability.
The parameters necessary for a planet's survival
are intrinsically and automatically
Law upon that planet.
A planet is a Host.
A civilization is a Guest.
A guest must respect their host
to remain worthy of hospitality.
No person, group, or institution
can ever hold any authority to override
the Law of the planet on which they reside.
101
Title 3: Ecology
The Prime Directive
The Prime Directive
Let it be.
Let the planet be.
Do not reduce Ecological Integrity
unless absolutely necessary.
Ecological Integrity
In all decisions affecting the Earth's biological systems,
the Law requires the course of action
that maximizes Ecological Integrity,
which has three factors:
1. Animate surface area –
the area of ground on which flora can grow;
2. Biodiversity –
the number of species interacting in the ecosystem;
3. Purity –
the absence of unnatural contaminants
in soil, water, and air.
The Three Forms of Ecological Degradation
1. Dis-animation –
converting a surface from animate to inanimate;
2. Eco-reduction –
reducing the number of species in the ecosystem;
3. Pollution –
contamination, chemical or otherwise,
that damages the ecosystem.
103
Commentary
THE PRIME DIRECTIVE
The Prime Directive is three words long because the principle is simple. The Earth knew how to run itself for billions of years before we arrived. The default is to leave it alone.
The three factors turn a vague ideal, "be good to nature," into something that can be measured and argued about. Does a proposal cover living soil with something dead? Does it reduce the number of species? Does it put something unnatural into the soil, water, or air? Most ecological harm falls under at least one of the three: paving a meadow, clearing a mixed forest for a single crop, dumping waste into a river.
104
Title 3: Ecology
Human Survival Necessity
Since survival requires some degree of ecological impact,
exemption from the Three Factors may be warranted
if all three Exemption Criteria are met:
1. the proposed action is necessary
to meet genuine needs;
2. no less harmful alternative exists;
3. council has been held, with the people of the place,
to determine the truth of the first two.
Genuine Needs
These are the needs that can potentially justify
the alteration of land:
full nutrition; clean, accessible water;
adequate temperature; comfortable sleeping;
convenient defecation; cleanliness and bathing;
protection from predators and insects;
medicine; social gathering;
and facilities for producing the tools or energy
necessary to fulfill these needs.
105
Commentary
HUMAN SURVIVAL NECESSITY
The Law does not pretend that human beings can live without touching the land. We have to eat, drink, sleep, and keep warm. All of that leaves a mark.
So the question is never "is there impact?" but "is this impact necessary, and is it the least it could be?" The list of genuine needs is deliberately basic, nearly identical to the biological and energetic levels of the Scale of Fundamentality in Title 1: Human Rights.
This does not mean nothing beyond survival may be built. It means land may not be degraded to make room for something unnecessary. A concert hall stacked on top of a dining hall takes no extra land. The same concert hall built on a cleared meadow does.
106
Title 3: Ecology
The Land Council
Land shall only be altered if doing so is wise.
To determine whether an alteration is wise,
council must be held to debate it.
Where
A Land Council is held
at the location of the proposed alteration.
Who
Decisions about land
rightfully belong to those
who are closest to the land.
In matters of land use, the land itself has the final say,
and those with the closest relationship to the land
have the final say in interpreting what that is.
Requirements
Anyone likely to be affected
is informed of the council, with ample notice.
Minds must be as clear as possible
before deliberation begins.
All arguments must be rationally evaluated.
Speech must be free, open, and uninterrupted.
107
Commentary
THE LAND COUNCIL
In the present system, decisions about a forest are often made in an office hundreds of miles away, by people who have never stood in it. The Land Council reverses that. The decision is made at the place itself, by the people who live there, with the land in front of them.
This is not mysticism. It is good epistemics. The person who has walked a hillside every morning for twenty years knows where the springs are, which slope floods, and where the owls nest. A distant planner looking at a map does not.
"The land has the final say" means the Council's job is to listen to the land, not to command it. Its question is not "what do we want?" but "what does this place need, and can our need be met without breaking it?"
108
Title 3: Ecology
The Land Council Protocol
In chronological order:
1. The time and location are announced in the local Village.
2. The council meets at the site of the proposed alteration.
3. Attendance is open to all.
4. Group meditation, seated in a circle on the ground,
to clear minds and get in touch with the Earth
before making decisions about the Earth.
5. An expression of reverence for the Earth,
such as kissing the ground or embracing a tree.
6. Discussion:
a. The proposer explains the proposal,
with time to explain all they believe needs explaining.
b. Questions are taken, as many as anyone has,
until all have been asked.
c. The chair asks: Is this alteration eco-benevolent?
Does it re-animate or dis-animate land?
Does it increase or decrease biodiversity?
Does it keep the land pure, or pollute it?
d. These are answered by arbitration,
according to the protocols of Rationality.
If eco-benevolent, proceed to the vote.
If degrading, continue:
e. Is the degradation necessary for meeting genuine needs?
Arbitration. If no, the project is rejected, and the council ends.
f. Is there a less harmful way to meet these needs?
Arbitration. If yes, the project is rejected, and the council ends.
If no, proceed to the vote.
7. A concluding meditation.
8. The vote is taken.
For a council's approval to be valid,
every step must be followed.
109
Commentary
THE LAND COUNCIL PROTOCOL
The protocol is a funnel. Most proposals that would harm the land never reach a vote at all, because they fail one of the questions along the way. If a project is good for the land, it passes straight through. If it harms the land, it has to prove that the harm is necessary and that no gentler path exists. Those proofs are tested by full rational arbitration, not by a show of hands.
Only after reason has done its work does the vote take place. And the meditation at the beginning and end is not decoration. A decision about a living place made in a hurry, in anger, or in greed tends to be a bad decision. The protocol slows people down long enough to remember what they are deciding about.
110
Title 3: Ecology
The Vote
The people who live closest to a place
are the most intimately familiar with it,
and thus most qualified to evaluate proposals affecting it.
Voting power is a function of proximity:
V = T ÷ D
V – the number of points a person's vote is worth;
T – the length of time they have dwelt nearby;
D – the distance of their dwelling from the place.
Supermajority
Land alterations require a two-thirds supermajority;
without it, no alteration is made.
All decisions must respect the Earth.
No person or group, not even a Land Council,
has any authority to violate the Hard Rules.
Appeals
Land Council decisions may be appealed
to the Village Council, at its regular meeting,
and from there to the Township, City, Regional,
and finally the High Council,
as each is willing to hear the dispute.
Only approvals of alterations may be appealed.
Rejections may not.
No greater level of social organization
may impose a land alteration upon an unwilling Village,
though it may overrule a Village's desire to alter the land.
If a higher council overrules a Village's plan
to alter land to meet its needs,
it must provide an alternative
that meets those needs with less ecological harm;
otherwise, it may not overrule.
111
Commentary
THE VOTE
The voting formula puts a number on a simple intuition: the longer you've lived somewhere, and the closer you live to it, the more your voice should count in deciding its fate. Someone who just arrived from the far side of the valley has a say, but less of one than the family who has lived beside the creek for three generations.
The appeals rule has a deliberate asymmetry, and it is the Prime Directive in procedural form. A decision to protect land is final. A decision to alter land can be challenged, all the way up. It is always easier to say "let it be" than to say "cut it down," because one of those mistakes can be undone and the other often can't.
The final clause prevents abuse in the other direction. A distant council can't simply veto a village's plan to meet its basic needs and walk away. If it says no, it has to offer a better way.
112
Title 3: Ecology
Soft Rules
Whereas the Hard Rules are non-negotiable,
exceptions may be made to the Soft Rules,
but only with the approval of a Land Council.
Trees
It is unlawful to fell any tree without Land Council approval.
Such council must be held at the foot of the tree in question.
No Land Council may approve the felling
of more than one tree per meeting.
Felling means cutting the trunk or any major branch,
digging that gravely disrupts the root system,
or building a structure that blocks most of its sunlight.
Construction
Except for temporary dwellings, such as tents and yurts,
it is unlawful to build anything upon living soil
without Land Council approval.
Digging and Mining
No material may be removed from the ground
without Land Council approval.
Water
It is unlawful to alter the course of any river or stream
without Land Council approval.
113
Commentary
SOFT RULES
The tree rule is the clearest example of how the Land Council works in practice. One tree, one meeting, held under that tree. You can't approve the clearing of a forest in an afternoon by voting on it as a single item. Each tree gets its own hearing, in its own shade.
That rule alone would make industrial logging impossible, and that is the point. A forest cut one considered tree at a time, with the community standing beneath each one, will never be clear-cut.
114
Title 3: Ecology
Hard Rules
Any activity that endangers the whole planet,
or eliminates entire ecosystems,
is universally unlawful, anywhere, at any time,
and beyond the authority of any Land Council to approve.
Fracking
It is unlawful to inject chemicals into the ground,
or to attack the structural integrity of the planet's crust.
All hydraulic fracturing equipment is contraband.
Strip Mining and Mountaintop Removal
It is unlawful to destroy the land's ability to support life.
All equipment for this purpose is contraband.
Dams
It is unlawful to dam a river so far
that entire ecosystems or villages are flooded and eliminated.
Existing dams must have fish ladders
that accommodate the largest aquatic animals
historically known to travel the river;
if this cannot be done, the dam must be dismantled.
Slashing and Burning
It is unlawful to deliberately set fire
to any forest, grassland, or brushland,
for any reason whatsoever.
Clear-Cutting
It is unlawful to cut two or more adjacent trees,
or any tree on the edge of the forest canopy.
It is unlawful to produce, distribute, or possess
machinery that expedites such destruction,
including all electric or fuel-powered timber machinery.
Backbone Species
It is unlawful to cut a healthy, mature, native tree
of a species that forms the backbone of its ecosystem.
Endangered Species
It is unlawful to harm any animal or plant
of any conservation status beyond Least Concern
on the IUCN scale.
115
Commentary
HARD RULES
The Hard Rules mark the activities that no human need could ever justify, because they destroy the conditions for meeting human needs at all. A village may argue about whether to cut one tree. No one may argue for poisoning an aquifer or burning a forest. The Land Council's authority stops here, and so does every other authority.
Several of these rules, such as the fish-ladder requirement, are phrased as practical tests. A dam is not banned outright. It is required to let the river's life pass through it, and if it can't, it has to go.
116
Title 3: Ecology
Hard Rules, continued
Weapons of Mass Destruction
It is unlawful to knowingly participate in, or support,
the construction, assembly, research, development, or testing
of nuclear, chemical, or biological weapons, or their parts.
All facilities used for this purpose
are mandated for immediate dismantling.
Nuclear Reactors
It is unlawful to construct new nuclear reactors,
or to mine or refine nuclear fuel.
Existing reactors may continue to use existing fuel,
until it is spent, or until safe sources mature to replace them.
Hazardous Waste
It is unlawful to export hazardous waste for storage.
All nuclear waste must be stored within the district
for which it provided energy.
All exported nuclear waste shall be returned
to the district that used it,
which is responsible for its storage in perpetuity.
Genetic Corruption of Organisms
No organism may be genetically altered
if it could contaminate the gene pool
of non-modified individuals
by breeding with them without further human assistance.
Particle Experiments
Any device capable of producing black holes or strangelets
shall be considered a weapon of mass destruction,
and placed under planetary custody.
No such experiment may be performed
without approval by a majority of the human population.
Pollution
It is unlawful to dump artificial or dangerous chemicals
into the water or the soil.
Any facility that deliberately does this
is warranted for immediate dismantling.
Crimes Against Nature
Whoever deliberately violates any Hard Rule
is guilty of a Crime Against Nature.
117
Commentary
HARD RULES, CONTINUED
The nuclear-waste rule is a principle of fairness: whoever used the energy keeps the waste. Today, a city can light its streets with nuclear power and ship the consequences to a poorer region far away. Under the Law of the Earth, the district that benefited carries the burden, which gives every district a powerful reason to choose cleaner energy.
The genetic-modification rule is precise. It doesn't forbid all genetic research. It forbids releasing changes that could spread into wild populations on their own, because once that happens, no one can take them back.
The particle-experiment rule is the one place in the Law that calls for a planetary vote. That isn't because a majority can create law. It's because an experiment with even a tiny chance of destroying the planet puts every person's life at stake, and no laboratory can claim the right to take that risk on behalf of eight billion people who were never asked.
118
Title 3: Ecology
Land Rights
Land is our home, not our property.
A member of an organization
cannot own the organization of which they are a member.
As a member of the ecosystem,
a human being may not own the ecosystem.
The finger cannot own the hand;
a person cannot own the land.
The greatest legal authority
anyone may unilaterally exercise upon land
is that of a Steward,
guarding and caring for the land's health.
Instead of ownership,
there are specific rights for specific uses,
from most universal to most specific:
1. Presence
2. Foraging
3. Hunting
4. Stewardship
5. Agriculture
6. Territorialization
7. Construction
8. Extraction
All of these, except Presence and Foraging,
are determined by the local Village.
Minerals, once extracted, belong to the human race.
119
Commentary
LAND RIGHTS
Title 1: Human Rights showed that no one can own land, because no one made it. This section answers the obvious next question: then who decides what happens on it?
The answer is a ladder of rights, each one tied to a particular use. The lowest rungs are universal. Anyone may walk the land, and anyone may eat a ripe fruit from it. The higher rungs are more specific, and they are granted by the Village that lives there. The more an activity would change the land, the higher up the ladder it sits, and the more it has to be justified.
"The finger cannot own the hand" is the whole argument in seven words. We are part of the ecosystem. A part cannot own the whole it belongs to.
120
Title 3: Ecology
Presence and Foraging
Presence
A person may walk anywhere on Earth, so long as they
do not trample plants clearly planted by someone,
take genuine care not to step on sensitive plants,
do not walk on an especially sensitive patch of ground,
and do not enter anyone's legitimate Personal Territory.
Foraging
Foraging is picking and eating directly,
carrying nothing away, except in one's stomach.
All people have the right to forage any botanical fruit,
meaning any part of a plant that is botanically a fruit,
even if it is eaten as a vegetable.
All people have the right to forage any other part of a plant,
so long as the species is not endangered,
and no crippling amount is taken from any one plant.
After foraging from a plant someone else planted,
the forager must make a good-faith effort
to help replenish what was taken,
unless meeting the planter would endanger the forager
because the planter does not acknowledge the Law.
Plucking
Plucking is foraging that seriously damages or kills a plant.
A person may pluck a food plant only if
they have the right to harvest it,
or they are starving, and no ordinary forage is available.
121
Commentary
PRESENCE AND FORAGING
Fruit is special in the Law because it is the part of the plant that wants to be eaten. A fruit is a plant's offer: eat this, and carry my seeds somewhere new. Taking it harms nothing. Taking leaves, stems, or roots is different, because those are what the plant needs to live, and so the Law sets limits.
The foraging right ends hunger without creating a loophole for harvest. You can eat your fill from any tree you walk past, but you can't fill a sack from a tree someone else planted. If you do eat from someone's garden, the honorable thing, and now the lawful thing, is to help them replant.
122
Title 3: Ecology
Hunting and Stewardship
Hunting
The local Village decides whether hunting is allowed,
and if so, how much.
If a species is in danger of being extirpated from an area
by excessive hunting or gathering,
a system of regulation and licensing may be used.
If such a system already exists and is not corrupt,
it may continue, with lawful authority.
Land Stewardship
Stewardship is deliberate but non-destructive change to land
that is not dis-animation, eco-reduction, or pollution,
and does not impede the movement of people or animals:
moving or carving rocks by hand;
shaping soil without powered machines;
chopping naturally fallen trees;
planting flora that does not reduce biodiversity;
caring for trees and shrubs;
keeping up existing footpaths;
making bridges of organic material;
making decorations and small shrines.
Stewardship involves no machines.
If machines are involved, the activity is a major alteration,
subject to Land Council.
Origin of the Stewardship Right
This right belongs to one person:
whoever has shown the most love for the land,
and the most competence in caring for it.
If more than one person claims it, these are weighed:
the length of time dwelling near the place;
the closeness of their sleeping space to it;
actions displaying love, such as planting or cleaning litter;
the condition of the land under their care;
and respect for the land, shown by keeping the Law.
Stewardship applies only to the area
immediately adjacent to one's dwelling.
123
Commentary
HUNTING AND STEWARDSHIP
Hunting is governed by the strict necessity test of Title 2: Animal Rights. This section only adds who sets the local limits: the Village, which knows its own animal populations best.
Stewardship is how the Law replaces ownership. A steward does not own the garden beside their home. They have earned the right to tend it, by loving it best and caring for it most. It is a right that is kept by doing the work, and it is lost by neglect or abuse. That is the opposite of a deed, which a landlord can hold forever without ever setting foot on the land.
124
Title 3: Ecology
Agriculture
All food production shall follow
Maximum Localization and Maximum Diversification.
Maximum Localization
All food shall be grown as near as possible
to where it is to be eaten.
Every household shall have its own garden
sufficient for its nutritional needs,
or be within walking distance of a shared garden that is.
Food shall not be transported long distances, except:
food that cannot grow in the local climate,
not even in a greenhouse;
while waiting for local crops of the same kind to mature;
or in famine, disaster, or humanitarian emergency.
Maximum Diversification
If a row of crops is so long and tedious
that heavy machinery is needed to farm it,
there are too many crops in a row.
It is unlawful to design farms as monocrops.
Food shall be grown in forest-garden arrangements,
different plants interspersed with one another,
woven between dwellings, throughout the village.
All existing monocrop fields shall be reduced in size each year,
and either converted into forest gardens
or regenerated into natural, mature forest.
Planting and Harvesting
Any person may plant any food plant
anywhere it will not harm or compete with another's planting,
unless that person gives permission.
A person may tend any plant they planted,
or have permission to tend.
Harvesting is picking and storing for later.
The right to harvest a plant comes from having planted it.
125
Commentary
AGRICULTURE
A field of one crop, stretching to the horizon, is a desert with a single species in it. It needs machines to plant, machines to spray, and machines to harvest, and it gives nothing back to the soil. The monocrop is the farming equivalent of the clear-cut.
The forest garden is the alternative, and it is ancient. Fruit trees overhead, berry bushes beneath them, vegetables and herbs at ground level, all growing together the way a natural forest does. It feeds people, shelters animals, and builds soil instead of depleting it. Woven through a village, it puts food within a few steps of every door.
The harvest right is the other half of the foraging rule. Anyone may eat a ripe fruit, but the stored harvest belongs to the one who planted it, because they made it grow.
126
Title 3: Ecology
Territorialization
Territorialization is the right to decide
who may enter or tread upon a piece of ground,
and to remove anyone who does not respect this.
The size of a territory
is the area of a circle of diameter V × H,
where H is one's height, from toe-tips to fingertips,
and V is a number set by the Village,
at least 1.5 and no greater than 5,
applying equally to all its residents.
Where territories are stacked in storeys,
the area may be multiplied by S,
the number of storeys.
A person is entitled to one territory.
It must be contiguous,
but need not be round.
A person may choose any location
not already claimed as another's territory,
and not designated a Sacred Space.
A Council at any level may declare
a Sacred Space within its jurisdiction.
127
Commentary
TERRITORIALIZATION
The limit on a territory is not a limit on how much space you can live in. It is a limit on how much space you can lawfully keep others out of.
You can live in a whole valley, walk all of it, tend gardens throughout it, and share its buildings with your neighbors. What you can't do is fence it and call it yours. The private space any person may defend is sized to the human body, enough for a home, and no more. Everything beyond it stays open to the people and animals who share the land.
128
Title 3: Ecology
Construction
Definition of a Building
Any affixment to land
of artificial products or substances
that cover the soil and deprive it of flora.
All architecture on Earth
must use the most advanced ecotechnology
available at the time of planning:
the art of providing for human needs
with as little impact on Nature as possible.
Every new building must meet these conditions:
1. Necessity – land is dis-animated only if the building
serves a genuine need.
2. Surface-Area Efficiency – it dis-animates no more land than its function requires,
or its function allows more land to be reforested.
3. Energy Efficiency – it uses natural heating and cooling,
shares climate control, and uses water efficiently.
4. Efficiency of Materials – it is built of the least damaging materials,
recycled and reused wherever possible.
5. Blending In – it blends with the ecosystem around it,
cuts no mature trees, and disturbs no sensitive area.
Build in the ecosystem, not on it.
6. Beauty – it aligns with the surrounding energy of the place,
draws on the building wisdom of the ancients,
and is pleasing to behold, pass by, and live in.
7. Green Roofing – it is small enough not to break the forest canopy,
or its unused roof is covered with soil and plants.
8. Shareability – it is open to be shared by as many as possible,
minimizing the need to build duplicates.
Building Space Allocation
Unnecessary duplication of facilities
strains the ecosystem,
so all facilities shall be shared to the extent reasonable,
and it is unlawful to use land surface
for a facility that is unnecessarily duplicative.
Facilities stacked in storeys upon others
use no extra land, and are not so restricted.
Location and Waiting Period
A building's location requires the approval
of both the Village Council and a Land Council.
Before building any permanent dwelling,
a person must first live on their territory
in a tent, yurt, or tipi for at least one season.
129
Commentary
CONSTRUCTION
Every building is a small death for the soil beneath it. That doesn't make building wrong, since people need shelter. But it means every building has to earn the ground it covers.
The eight conditions read like a design brief, and that is what they are. A building that meets all eight is small, efficient, beautiful, shared, and alive on its roof. It looks less like a modern subdivision and more like a village that grew out of the forest.
The waiting period may be the wisest rule in the section. Live on the land for a season before you build. Learn where the sun falls in winter, where the wind comes from, and where the water runs when it rains. Then build, if you still want to.
Note the shift from duplication to sharing. One village workshop, used by everyone, instead of a garage in every house. Shared facilities save land, and they also bring people together.
130
Title 3: Ecology
Transportation
Footpaths
Footpaths are the paths most natural to humanity,
and most preferred by the planet.
They are made by walking, and need no machinery.
Wherever enough people walk, footpaths form.
If a path requires machinery to make,
it is by definition not a footpath.
Tools may be used to smooth existing footpaths.
A village is, by definition, compact enough to walk,
so the only pathways within a village are footpaths.
RoadRails
All new roads must combine several kinds of transit,
layered over the same space.
A RoadRail is an elevated railway
over a paved way for bicycles, scooters, and vehicles.
Every RoadRail shall be:
elevated; quiet; paved underneath;
fitted with chargers at every stop;
narrow enough for an unbroken tree canopy above it;
shaped to the contours of the land;
non-intrusive, felling no large mature trees,
crossing no old-growth forest,
and passing around villages, never through them;
consensual, approved by every steward
of the land it crosses;
and, where funds are short,
built in stages, the lower way first.
Wherever fenced, it must let small animals pass freely,
with living land-bridges for large animals
at every kilometer.
Automobile Roads
It is unlawful to build new stand-alone automobile roads.
Existing roads of two lanes or fewer may be maintained.
Highways of three or more undivided lanes
are scars upon the Earth,
unlawful to build or maintain,
and shall be dismantled or reduced to two lanes.
Air Travel
The purpose of air travel is to cross large bodies of water.
All new routes over dry land
shall be footpaths or RoadRails.
Existing air routes over land may continue
during the transition to surface travel,
but no new routes over land shall be established.
New airports may be built only beside the shoreline
of the water they are meant to cross.
131
Commentary
TRANSPORTATION
Roads are among the most destructive things human beings build. They cover enormous areas of living soil, they cut every ecosystem they cross in half, and they make it possible to reach and destroy places that would otherwise be left alone.
The RoadRail is the Law's answer: stack the transit instead of spreading it. A train above, a cycle and scooter way below, all on one narrow strip under the trees, curving around the land rather than blasting through it, and never cutting through a village. Villages themselves are joined by footpaths alone, which make themselves wherever people walk.
132
Title 3: Ecology
Natural Resources
Sustainable Management
As resources are finite,
a community may establish a Sustainable Management Authority,
elected by all who depend upon the resource,
to manage its use on behalf of them and their posterity.
Water
It is unlawful to irrigate in a way
that permanently depletes existing bodies of water.
Anyone who depends on a body of water
has a say in its use.
Energy
People may install renewable, non-disruptive energy devices
on, or within a stone's throw of, their own habitation.
Villages may build energy infrastructure for their own use,
and every village shall aim to be energy self-sufficient.
Existing long-distance grids may be maintained, but not expanded.
All power lines run along RoadRails,
and underground within a village.
Fossil Fuels
The purpose of fossil fuels
is to power civilization temporarily,
until clean, renewable energy matures.
Fossil fuels are not for economic growth.
Unsustainable, fossil-fuel-based growth
shall cease immediately and completely,
and shall not resume until it can be sustained.
Meanwhile, existing energy and farming networks
may continue, to keep society stable.
Planetization of Fossil Fuels
The planet's remaining fossil-fuel resources and infrastructure
are placed under the collective management of the human race,
on behalf of all people on Earth.
This is not an entitlement to use them,
but to an equal share of the benefit, if they are used.
All future revenue from fossil fuels
shall go to the research, development, and production
of clean, renewable energy.
Moratorium on Mining
No mineral may be mined
until it has been recovered from every accessible landfill,
and that supply is exhausted.
It is unlawful to open a new mine
for a mineral that can still be supplied by recycling.
133
Commentary
NATURAL RESOURCES
Fossil fuels are not treated as evil. They are treated as a bridge. They are useful for getting from where we are to where we need to be, and dangerous to mistake for the destination.
Planetization follows from Land Rights. Oil and coal were laid down over millions of years. No one made them. They belong, if to anyone, to everyone. So the benefit of every barrel goes to everyone, and every cent of revenue goes toward ending the need for the next barrel.
The mining moratorium recognizes a simple fact. Our landfills already hold enormous quantities of metal that we dug up once and threw away. Before we tear open another mountain, we have to recover what we already have.
134
Title 3: Ecology
Waste and Restoration
Compulsory Recycling
All refuse shall be recycled;
there shall be no more dumps or landfills.
Responsibility for Recycling
Any company that sells non-biodegradable products
in an area without the means to recycle them
is responsible for collecting and recycling them.
If a product is too costly to recycle,
it shall not be manufactured in the first place.
Organic Waste
All non-hazardous organic waste
shall be returned to the soil,
unenclosed by any non-organic container.
Existing sewage systems may be maintained, but not expanded.
Suppression of Regeneration
It is unlawful to deliberately suppress
the natural regeneration of an ecosystem
for any reason other than genuine sustenance.
All land deprived of its natural forest,
and not serving a useful function for the community,
must be allowed to regenerate
into its natural mature forest.
Lawns
A lawn that people play on
needs no machine to keep it short,
because the playing does that job.
A lawn played on enough to justify mowing
needs no mowing, because of the playing.
If a lawn requires mowing,
it is not played on enough to justify it.
135
Commentary
WASTE AND RESTORATION
In nature there is no such thing as waste. Every fallen leaf, every dead tree, every animal's dung becomes food for something else. "Waste" is a human invention, and the Law asks us to un-invent it. Whatever comes from the soil goes back to the soil, and whatever is made must be made so it can be made again.
The responsibility rule puts the cost where it belongs. A company that wants to sell plastic in a place that cannot recycle it can do so, as long as it takes the plastic back. If that is too expensive to bear, the product was never truly affordable. Someone else was simply paying for it.
The lawn rule has a smile in it, but it is serious logic, and it explains why the lawnmower appears on the contraband list in Title 1: Human Rights. A lawn is a field kept in permanent infancy, forbidden by a machine from growing up into what it wants to become. If no one is playing on it, let it grow.
136
Commentary
THE PLANET IS AN ORGANISM
Human beings are one species in an ecosystem made of many, and our survival depends on its integrity. Without a healthy biosphere, the principles of this Law could not be agreed with or disagreed with, because there would be no one left to debate them. That is why the health of the ecosystem is the third of the Three Affirmations of Sanity in Title 4: Upholdment. It isn't one value among others. It is the precondition for having values at all.
The Earth is a dynamic system, in which an alteration in any one place can affect every other place. In a complex ecosystem there is no such thing as an "isolated incident." The river poisoned upstream reaches the village downstream. The forest cleared on one continent changes the rain on another.
The metaphor of host and guest says the rest. A guest who respects the house is welcome indefinitely. A guest who burns the furniture for warmth will not be a guest much longer.
102