Rationality

The Hot Seat

Walking someone through their own reasoning.

On the Hot Seat, one party asks questions to examine the other's logic.

How It Works

The questioner directs the conversation, temporarily. The one on the Hot Seat must follow it, answering what is asked, and only what is asked, without evading, changing the subject, or adding material. Answers must be as simple as possible, followed by silence, so the questioner can go on.

Logic, Not Trivia

The Hot Seat examines logic, not knowledge of facts. Questions about facts may be asked, but answering them is optional. Questions about how the other person's reasoning flows must be answered.

Why It Exists

Proving anything takes steps. To show that A leads to C, you first get agreement that A leads to B, then that B leads to C, and only then can the two be put together. The only way to walk someone through those steps is to direct the conversation for a while. The other person has to follow along to judge the logic at all. Following is not agreeing: if they spot a flaw, they can say so.

Taking Turns

The claimant may place the defendant on the Hot Seat in Phase 1, and the defendant may place the claimant on it in Phase 2. Each side gets its turn to lead.