Rationality

The Five Rational Responses

Every reply must be one of these.

In arbitration, every reply to an argument must take one of five forms.

  1. Questioning: asking a question.
  2. Answering: giving a statement in reply to a question.
  3. Concurring: "I concur."
  4. Rebutting: with contrary evidence, or a logical flaw. See Rebuttals.
  5. Conceding: "You are right."

What's Left Out

Anything else is not a rational response: changing the subject, insulting the speaker, walking away, or answering a different question than the one asked. An argument that hasn't been answered in one of these five ways hasn't been refuted. It still stands.

Conceding Is Honorable

Conceding a point is not losing. It is finding out what's true, which is the whole purpose. Refusing to concede an argument that has clearly been refuted is a breach of Decorum.