Nature vs. Technolatry

You're Not the First

Those who saw it coming.

If you've ever felt uneasy about the direction of technology, and wondered whether you were the only one, you're not. People have been warning about technolatry for as long as it's existed. They were usually ignored. Here are some of them.

Plato (about 370 BC)

In the Phaedrus, Plato tells of an Egyptian king who is offered the invention of writing. He refuses to praise it, warning that it will "create forgetfulness in the learners' souls, because they will not use their memories" (Plato, Phaedrus). (See The Disembodied Human.)

The Luddites (1811 to 1816)

The Luddites were English textile workers who broke the machines that were destroying their trades and their communities (Wikipedia). Their name became an insult for anyone who questions technology. But they weren't against all tools. They were against being made the servants of machines owned by someone else.

Mary Shelley (1818)

Frankenstein, often called the first science fiction novel, is the story of a brilliant man who creates a new kind of being, and then can't control what he's made (Wikipedia). Its subtitle is The Modern Prometheus.

Henry David Thoreau (1854)

In Walden, Thoreau wrote that "men have become the tools of their tools" (Walden). He went to live in a cabin by a pond, to see how little a person really needs.

Samuel Butler (1863)

Only four years after Darwin's On the Origin of Species, the novelist Samuel Butler published a letter called "Darwin Among the Machines." He argued that machines were evolving, and that "we are ourselves creating our own successors." He called for war against them, before it was too late (Wikipedia). That was more than 150 years before today's talk of "AI succession." (See The Ten Tenets of Technolatry.)

Mahatma Gandhi (1909)

In Hind Swaraj, Gandhi criticized modern industrial civilization, and its machinery, as a source of moral decay (Wikipedia). His spinning wheel became a symbol of self-reliance at the village scale.

Lewis Mumford (1934 to 1970)

The historian Lewis Mumford traced technology back to the ancient world, and coined the word "megamachine" for the great organizations of people, beginning with the armies and work gangs of the first kings, that are run like machines (Wikipedia). (See The False Promises of Technolatry.)

C. S. Lewis (1943)

In The Abolition of Man, Lewis warned that "what we call Man's power over Nature turns out to be a power exercised by some men over other men with Nature as its instrument" (Wikipedia). He also named the habit of assuming that whatever is newer must be better: he called it "chronological snobbery" (C. S. Lewis Institute).

Jacques Ellul (1954)

In The Technological Society, the French thinker Jacques Ellul argued that "technique," the drive for efficiency in everything, had become a force of its own, shaping society to its needs, rather than serving human ones (Wikipedia).

E. F. Schumacher (1973)

Schumacher's Small Is Beautiful carries the subtitle A Study of Economics As If People Mattered. He called for technology at a human scale, which communities could own, understand, and control (Wikipedia). (See The Multi-Layered Economy.)

Ivan Illich (1973)

In Tools for Conviviality, Illich drew a line between tools that extend people's own abilities, which he called "convivial" tools, and industrial tools that grow past that point and begin to undermine human freedom and skill (Wikipedia).

Wendell Berry (1987)

The Kentucky farmer and writer Wendell Berry explained, in an essay called "Why I Am Not Going to Buy a Computer," why he'd keep writing by hand (Wikipedia). He has spent his life defending small farms, local communities, and care for the land.

Neil Postman (1992)

In Technopoly, Postman described a culture that demands the "submission of all forms of cultural life to the sovereignty of technique and technology" (Wikipedia). That's very close to what we call technolatry.

The Amish (from the 1700s to today)

The Amish have done more than warn. They've shown, community by community, for generations, that a people can decide for themselves which tools to accept, and which to refuse. (See Who Steers?.)

Ted Kaczynski

No list like this can leave out Ted Kaczynski, the "Unabomber," whose mail bombs killed three people and injured many more between 1978 and 1995. He pleaded guilty in 1998 (Wikipedia).

Mailing bombs to people is murder. If he mailed those bombs, then he was a murderer, and nothing excuses it. Some suspect he was set up to discredit the cause. But either way, the bombings did that, too. They made everyone who questions technology look dangerous and unhinged, and they made a killer the public face of the opposition to technolatry.

And yet none of that changes whether his observations were true. Many of his predictions about where technology was taking society, toward dependence, surveillance, and the loss of human autonomy, have proven right on the money. That's because truth is independent of the character who reveals it. A true statement doesn't become false because a murderer said it. (See Be Loyal to Truth.)

The Earth Party rejects his violence completely. Nothing about the critique of technology requires harming anyone. Our way is the opposite of his: persuasion, consent, and building something better, one village at a time.

You're in Good Company

From ancient Greece to the present day, people from every background, Christian and secular, poet and historian, farmer and philosopher, have seen the same thing. The question was never whether anyone noticed. It's whether, this time, enough of us will act on it.