Nature vs. Technolatry

Science's Track Record

Things we were told were safe.

Technolatry asks us to trust that each new invention is safe, and that the experts have it under control. Before we do, it's worth looking at the record.

Every item below was once approved, recommended, or declared harmless by the scientific and medical authorities of its day. Every one was later restricted, withdrawn, or abandoned.

A List of Reversals

Things We Ate, Drank, and Breathed

  • Tobacco. In the 1940s and 1950s, doctors appeared in cigarette ads, and one brand claimed that "more doctors smoke Camels" (Stanford Research into the Impact of Tobacco Advertising). In 1964, the U.S. Surgeon General's report linked smoking to lung cancer (National Library of Medicine).
  • Leaded gasoline. Lead was added to gasoline beginning in the 1920s, and for decades the industry insisted it was safe. It was finally ended worldwide in 2021 (Wikipedia).
  • Lead paint. Lead paint was used in homes for generations, until the United States banned it for residential use in 1978 (Wikipedia).
  • Lead pipes. Lead pipes carried drinking water into millions of homes. The EPA now says there's no known safe level of lead in the blood of children (EPA).
  • Trans fats. Partially hydrogenated oils were promoted as a healthier alternative to butter and lard. In 2015, the FDA ruled that they were no longer "generally recognized as safe," and ordered them out of the food supply (Wikipedia).
  • Sugar. In the 1960s, a sugar industry group paid Harvard scientists to play down sugar's role in heart disease, and to point the blame at fat instead (NPR).
  • Radium tonics. In the 1920s, bottled radium water was sold as a health tonic. One wealthy man who drank it daily died in 1932, after his jaw had disintegrated (Wikipedia).

Things in Our Homes

  • Asbestos. Once prized as a miracle fireproofing material, asbestos causes lung cancer and mesothelioma. The United States didn't ban its last remaining uses until 2024 (EPA).
  • BPA. A chemical used in hard plastics and can linings, BPA can mimic estrogen in the body. It was removed from baby bottles in the United States in 2012 (Wikipedia).
  • PFOA and Teflon. A chemical used to make nonstick pans was later linked to cancer and other illness, and was phased out by U.S. manufacturers by 2015. It's one of the "forever chemicals" that now turn up in water and in people around the world (EPA, Wikipedia).
  • Flame retardants. PBDEs were added to furniture, carpets, and electronics for decades, until concerns about their effects on health led U.S. manufacturers to phase them out (Wikipedia).
  • Plastic microbeads. Tiny plastic beads were added to face scrubs and toothpaste, and washed by the billions into rivers and oceans, until the United States banned them in 2015 (Wikipedia).

Things We Sprayed

  • DDT. Once sprayed freely on crops, in homes, and even on people, DDT was found to poison wildlife and thin the eggshells of birds. The EPA banned it in 1972 (EPA).
  • CFCs. Chemicals used in refrigerators and spray cans turned out to be destroying the ozone layer. They were phased out under the Montreal Protocol of 1987 (Wikipedia).
  • Atrazine. A weed killer still widely used in the United States, atrazine was banned in the European Union in 2004, because of its contamination of groundwater (Wikipedia).

Medicine

  • Thalidomide. Sold in the late 1950s as a safe sedative, and given to pregnant women for morning sickness, thalidomide caused severe birth defects in thousands of babies before it was withdrawn (Wikipedia).
  • Vioxx. A widely prescribed painkiller, Vioxx was withdrawn in 2004, after it was found to raise the risk of heart attack and stroke (Wikipedia).
  • Diet pills. Amphetamines were widely prescribed for weight loss in the mid-1900s. Later, the popular "fen-phen" combination was pulled from the market in 1997, after it was linked to heart valve damage (Wikipedia).
  • X-rays of pregnant women. Pregnant women were routinely X-rayed, until the researcher Alice Stewart showed in the 1950s that it raised the risk of cancer in their children (Wikipedia).
  • Mercury. Teething powders containing mercury were once given to babies, causing a disease called acrodynia, or "pink disease" (Wikipedia). Mercury is still used in some dental fillings, but in 2020 the FDA recommended against them for pregnant women, children, and other high-risk groups (Wikipedia).
  • Tanning beds. Once marketed as a safe way to tan, tanning beds were classified as a cause of cancer by the World Health Organization's cancer agency in 2009 (Wikipedia).
  • The lobotomy. The surgeon who invented it won the Nobel Prize in 1949 (Nobel Prize). Tens of thousands of people were lobotomized before the practice was abandoned (Wikipedia).

Mind and Family

  • Formula over breast milk. For much of the 1900s, formula was promoted as equal or superior to breast milk. Aggressive marketing in poor countries led to a worldwide boycott of Nestlé in 1977 (Wikipedia), and to the World Health Organization's code on the marketing of breast milk substitutes in 1981 (WHO).
  • "Don't touch the baby." In 1928, the psychologist John B. Watson advised parents never to hug or kiss their children, for fear of spoiling them (Wikipedia). Later research, including Harry Harlow's studies of infant monkeys, showed how badly the young need comfort and touch (Wikipedia).
  • Homosexuality as a disorder. Homosexuality was listed as a mental disorder by the American Psychiatric Association until 1973 (Drescher, Behavioral Sciences), and gay people were subjected to "treatments" that included electric shocks (Wikipedia).
  • Phrenology. In the 1800s, respected scientists claimed that character and intelligence could be read from the shape of the skull (Wikipedia).

One Man

Thomas Midgley Jr. was a celebrated chemist of the early 1900s. He discovered that adding lead to gasoline stopped engines from knocking. He then helped develop CFCs for refrigeration. Both were hailed as triumphs. Both turned out to be disasters for the planet, and one writer has called him "a one-man environmental disaster" (New Scientist). Midgley himself was poisoned by lead during his work (Wikipedia, Britannica).

Two of the most harmful inventions of the twentieth century came from the mind of a single, brilliant, well-intentioned man. That's the point. Brilliance and good intentions are no protection against unintended consequences.

Still Debated

The following are still under active scientific dispute. We list them here, not as settled reversals, but as examples where official reassurance has been challenged by other official bodies.

  • Glyphosate. In 2015, the World Health Organization's cancer agency classified this widely used weed killer as "probably carcinogenic to humans" (IARC). Other regulators, including the EPA, have disagreed.
  • Aspartame. In 2023, the same agency classified this artificial sweetener as "possibly carcinogenic to humans," while a separate WHO committee kept its recommended daily limit unchanged (WHO).
  • Fluoride. In 2024, the U.S. National Toxicology Program concluded, with moderate confidence, that fluoride exposures above 1.5 milligrams per liter are associated with lower IQ in children. That's about twice the level recommended for U.S. drinking water (NTP).

The Common Thread

To science's credit, in every case on this list, it was eventually scientists who uncovered the harm. Science can correct itself. The trouble is the lag: the years, and sometimes the generations, between the confident rollout and the quiet withdrawal, during which people are harmed.

And there's a pattern in the mistakes. Again and again, the error was the same: assuming that a part could be changed without affecting the whole. That a chemical in the paint wouldn't reach the child, that a spray on the field wouldn't reach the birds, that a gas in the refrigerator wouldn't reach the sky.

But every part is connected to the whole, and the whole is connected to every part. So every part is connected to every other part.

That's why the burden of proof should rest on the new, and not the old. Before something unnatural is introduced into the world, its makers should have to show that it's safe, rather than leaving the rest of us to prove, decades later, that it wasn't.