Nature vs. Technolatry

The Disembodied Human

From symbols to screens, and the way back to the body.

For almost all of human history, we lived in our bodies. We knew the world by touching it, smelling it, walking through it, and working it with our hands. We knew one another by voice, face, gesture, and touch.

Step by step, technolatry has pulled us out of the body and into a world of symbols. That journey began long before the screen.

Life in Symbols

Writing was the first great step. Before it, knowledge lived in people: in memory, in song, in story, and in the skilled hands of those who passed it on. Writing moved knowledge out of the person and onto the page. It turned the living world into marks that stand for things, rather than the things themselves.

That change was noticed, and worried over, from the very beginning. In Plato's Phaedrus, written about 2,400 years ago, an Egyptian king warns the inventor of writing that it will "create forgetfulness in the learners' souls, because they will not use their memories" (Plato, Phaedrus).

Writing has given us a great deal. You're reading this. But it also began to train the human mind to live in a world of symbols, at one remove from the body and the present moment. Each later invention, the printing press, the telegraph, the radio, the television, the computer, and the phone, took us a step further in the same direction.

Somatic Amnesia

The writer Tim Vacha has a name for where that journey has now arrived: somatic amnesia. People, he writes, "are rapidly starting to largely forget they even have bodies" (Tim Vacha on X).

It used to be that for our minds to socialize with other minds, our bodies had to socialize with other bodies. We shared physical space. We heard the vibration of each other's voices and laughter, saw each other's faces, and felt each other's presence. And all of that reflected back to us our own sense of being embodied.

Social media broke that link. It made it possible for minds to socialize with each other without bodies at all. Pornography goes further, turning the most embodied experience of all into something that happens in the mind, in response to an image on a screen. Vacha argues that the habit carries over into real life, where many people now experience intimacy itself as a movement of the mind, rather than a meeting of bodies.

Taken together, these technologies teach us to think of ourselves as minds, rather than as living, embodied beings.

Why It Matters

The body isn't just a vehicle for the mind. As Vacha puts it, "The body is the dimension in which the mind can unknot itself."

So many of the loops and dead ends that trap the mind are dissolved by returning to the body, by walking, dancing, working, touching, and breathing. When it's experienced fully, the body and the mind aren't easily separated. Vacha again: "To unplug it from the body is like uprooting a plant from its soil."

A mind cut off from the body is also cut off from the intuition that lives there: the gut feeling that something is wrong, the sense of when to trust and when to hold back. That's part of what makes a disembodied people so easy to persuade. (See The False Promises of Technolatry.)

The Last Step

Technolatry's final hope is to finish the journey: to leave the body behind entirely, by uploading the mind into a machine. In that vision, the body is just a temporary container, and the mind is just information. (See The Machine God.)

But if the mind is uprooted from its soil, what's left isn't a freer mind. It's a dying one.

The Way Back

The way home doesn't begin with a new invention. It begins with the body.

  • Gather in person, and let conversation happen face to face.
  • Dance, sing, make music, and move together.
  • Work with your hands, in gardens and workshops.
  • Walk, and spend time outdoors, in living places.
  • Touch, and be touched, with care and consent.

As Vacha concludes, much of our society's way back consists simply of "a journey back to living in our bodies."