The previous article laid out the ten tenets of technolatry, the worship of technology, in the words of the people who hold them. This article answers them, one at a time.
None of the answers below say that tools are evil, or that we should throw away everything invented since the Stone Age. A spear, a pot, a well, and a warm house are not the problem. The problem is the belief that technology is our salvation, that it should advance without limits, and that nothing, including us, should be allowed to stand in its way.
1. "The story of human progress is the story of technology."
Answer: That's the story of our tools, not the story of us.
Our species is a few hundred thousand years old. Farming is about 12,000 years old. Writing is about 5,000. For nearly all of our time on Earth, we lived without the technologies the history books are built around, and we weren't waiting around for them to arrive.
There's also a quiet bias in the way the story gets told. "History," by definition, begins with writing, and writing is itself a technology. So the official record starts at the moment technology took over, and everything before it gets filed away as "prehistory," as though it were a waiting room.
Meanwhile, the things that actually make a human life good, such as love, friendship, wisdom, art, music, play, health, and belonging to a place, don't show up on the timeline of tools at all. If progress means a better life, then progress has to be measured by the quality of life, not by the sophistication of the gadgets.
2. "All solutions to all problems are technological."
Answer: First ask where the problem came from.
In most cases, the problem was caused by a previous technology. Then a new technology gets invented to solve it, which creates the next problem, which calls for the next invention. That isn't solving problems. It's patching the patches, and then patching the patches of the patches. (See The Technolatric Dialectic.)
A sane person and a technolater respond to the same mistake in opposite ways. Say that genetically modifying our food makes it cheaper to grow, but harmful to eat. The sane person says, "Let's stop genetically modifying our food." The technolater says, "Let's genetically modify humans to tolerate the modified food."
Often, the real solution isn't a new invention at all. It's stopping. When leaded gasoline turned out to poison the developing brains of children around the world (New Scientist), the fix wasn't a cleverer additive. It was taking the lead out.
3. "Any technology that can be invented should be invented."
Answer: "Can" has never meant "should."
Thomas Midgley was one of the most celebrated inventors of the 20th century. He solved two urgent problems of his day. To stop engines from knocking, he gave the world leaded gasoline. To replace dangerous refrigerator gases, he gave it CFCs (Britannica). Both were brilliant solutions. Both were later banned, the first for its damage to human health and the second for destroying the ozone layer (Wikipedia). One man, with good intentions, poisoned the planet twice.
Notice who received the benefits and who paid the costs. Midgley's company chose lead partly because it could be patented, and it calculated it could make three cents on every gallon sold (New Scientist). The profits went to a few. The damage went to everyone.
And here's the part that makes caution essential: every new field of technology crosses a bridge, and then burns the bridge behind it. Once a technology is woven into the world, the world comes to depend on it, and going back becomes painful or impossible. That means the decision to introduce a technology is, in practice, nearly permanent. Decisions that permanent deserve more care, not less.
A few examples:
- Cars paved over the gardens. Roads and parking lots now cover land that could be growing our food, if we didn't depend on the supermarkets the cars were built to take us to.
- MapQuest and GPS replaced the atlas. Most people can no longer find their way with a paper map, so when the signal drops, they're lost.
- Banks moved from paper ledgers to computers. Your savings now exist as entries in a database, with no paper record to fall back on if the system fails.
- Dating apps replaced the approach. The skill of meeting someone in person, at a dance or in a market, is fading for a whole generation.
- AI is writing the code. As programmers hand more of their work to AI, fewer people learn to write the fundamental code the internet runs on. A higher level, AI, is becoming the thing that keeps the level below it, the internet, standing. That's the pyramid turned upside down.
Burning the Bridges gathers as many of these as we can find.
4. "Even useless technology pushes us toward a complexity that will eventually make life better."
Answer: Why would the trend suddenly reverse?
For thousands of years, each new layer of complexity has brought new burdens along with its benefits: more work, more maintenance, more dependence, more ways for things to break. If the trend so far has been to trade our freedom and health for more machinery, there's no reason to believe that piling on still more machinery will flip the result.
The usual reply is that once technology becomes powerful enough, it will finally deliver. But power does not bestow wisdom. If it did, tyrants with absolute power would be the wisest and kindest people on Earth. (See The Machine God.) More power in the hands of a system that has been making the same mistakes for millennia only lets it make bigger ones.
Complexity also brings fragility. A person on foot depends on two legs and the ground. A person in a truck depends on the truck, the fuel, the refinery, the oil field, the roads, the parts suppliers, the mechanics, and the economy that holds all of them together. Every new link is another place for the chain to break.
5. "Artifice is superior to Nature."
Answer: The maker can't outdo the thing that made him.
The human mind is part of Nature. If Nature is so flawed that it needs to be replaced, then the human mind, which is part of Nature, is flawed too, and so is everything it builds. A technology designed by the human mind therefore carries two layers of potential error: the error of the mind, built on whatever error exists in the world that made the mind. Two Layers of Creation explores this "double mistake" in full.
Look at what Nature builds compared with what we build. A spider spins silk that is tougher than Kevlar (Wikipedia), and it does so silently, at the temperature of a garden, out of protein and water, with no factory, no toxic waste, and no supply chain. Our best materials need furnaces, solvents, and global industry, and they still don't match it on every measure.
The belief in artifice's superiority also depends on shrinking Nature down to a machine first. Once a human being is described as an "algorithm," a better algorithm sounds like an upgrade. But a description isn't the thing it describes. A map of a forest isn't a forest, and a model of a mind isn't a mind.
6. "The purpose of biological life is to serve as a stepping stone to artificial life."
Answer: Who decided that?
This isn't a scientific finding. It's a theological claim, a statement about the meaning and purpose of life, made by people who usually say they don't believe in meaning or purpose. Life flourished on this planet for billions of years without silicon chips. Nothing in its history suggests it was waiting for them.
The relationship actually runs the other way. Every level of complexity in the world rests on the level beneath it. Plants rest on soil, animals rest on plants, and human societies rest on all of them. Computers rest on human societies: on the miners, engineers, farmers, power workers, and everyone who feeds and supports them. Artificial intelligence sits at the very top of that pyramid, which makes it the most dependent thing on Earth, not the destination everything else was leading to. The Pyramid of Technological Emergence describes this in detail.
7. "Artificial life, being superior, will replace humanity."
Answer: Superior at what?
A computer can calculate faster than any person. But a human being can heal its own wounds, feed itself from plants and sunlight, make new humans, survive without electricity, and adapt to almost any climate on Earth. No machine can do any of that on its own. Take away the power grid, the supply chains, and the people who maintain them, and every data center in the world eventually goes dark.
Machines also inherit our errors, and then add their own. Everything a machine knows about the world, it knows through what humans built into it. Each layer of imitation drifts a little further from the original, and small errors compound. An intelligence built on a copy of a copy isn't likely to manage the living world better than the beings who grew up inside it.
And even if a machine were superior in every way, superiority isn't a license. A stronger person doesn't gain the right to replace a weaker one.
8. "This replacement will be a good thing."
Answer: How dare anyone decide that for the rest of us.
No one has the authority to consent, on behalf of eight billion people and all who come after them, to the end of the human race. Not a billionaire, not a professor, not a conference, not a government.
Consider how we treat other threats. A person who threatens to attack a school is arrested. People who speak calmly about replacing the entire human species are given keynote speeches. According to Elon Musk's sworn testimony, Larry Page called him a "speciesist" for preferring humans to AI (The Economic Times). But every living thing is "speciesist" in that sense. A mother bear defending her cubs is speciesist. Caring whether your own children have a future isn't a prejudice. It's the most basic loyalty there is.
9. "This entire pathway is inevitable."
Answer: If it were inevitable, nobody would need to keep saying so.
The claim of inevitability is a sales pitch. It tells you not to bother resisting, because resistance is pointless. But companies that believe their future is guaranteed don't spend fortunes persuading the public and lobbying lawmakers.
People have refused technologies before. Leaded gasoline and CFCs were both pulled from common use once their harms were understood, along with a long list of others (Science's Track Record) (Wikipedia). The Amish have spent generations deciding, community by community, which technologies to accept and which to refuse, asking whether a new tool will "bolster our life together, as a community, or is it going to somehow tear it down?" (NPR) The writer Kevin Kelly, who studied them, observed that "they ban more than they adopt," and that their choices "are not individual, but communal" (The Technium).
Technology has no will of its own. It goes wherever people take it. The only thing that makes the current path inevitable is the belief that it is.
10. "Anyone who wants to restrict or redirect technology is backwards."
Answer: Sometimes backwards is the right direction.
C. S. Lewis put it this way: "progress means getting nearer to the place you want to be and if you have taken a wrong turning, then to go forward does not get you any nearer. If you are on the wrong road, progress means doing an about-turn and walking back to the right road; and in that case, the man who turns back soonest is the most progressive man." (C. S. Lewis Institute)
The precautionary principle, which Andreessen calls "deeply immoral," is simply how every living creature survives. An animal doesn't eat an unfamiliar plant just because it can. A sensible person doesn't drive faster around a blind curve. Brakes and a steering wheel don't make a car backwards. They're what make it safe to drive at all.
As for who should do the steering: not a single world authority, and not a handful of billionaires. The steering belongs to every level of society, each deciding for its own jurisdiction, the way each Amish community decides for itself.
And the kind of technology each level decides on grows with its scale. A village decides about the tools of daily life on its own common ground: screens in the commons, sprays on the gardens, engines on the footpaths. A township decides about the machinery of craft and trade. A city decides about heavy industry, and a metropolis about power plants and the grid. The largest and most far-reaching technologies, such as AI, are decided at the widest scale of all.
These decisions are agreements among the people who live there, not orders backed by force. The Law of the Earth sets the outer limits for everyone, and within those limits, every community keeps the right to say no, and the right to change its mind. Who Steers? explains how it works.
What's Left Standing
Take away the ten tenets, and what remains is a simple, older idea: technology is a servant. It's good when it serves Life, and harmful when Life is made to serve it. A tool that keeps people warm, fed, and healthy, without threatening the land or making us dependent on something fragile, is a good tool. A tool that does the opposite isn't progress, no matter how impressive it is.
The question is how to tell the two apart. The answer is the pyramid of technological emergence, the subject of the next article.

