Nature vs. Technolatry

A Phased Backtrack to Aboriginality

Unwinding the web, newest strand first.

If technolatry has taken us down the wrong road, how do we turn around?

Not all at once. Throwing away every machine overnight would be its own kind of disaster, because so much of life now depends on them. (See Another Place for the Chain to Break.) And it wouldn't be done by force, because the Earth Party has no power of force, and wants none.

Instead, we can unwind the technolatric web the way it was woven, strand by strand, but in reverse: starting with the newest strands, and working backwards.

The Goal

The goal isn't to return to the Stone Age. It's to live, day to day, as close as we can to the way our aboriginal ancestors lived: outdoors, in our bodies, among neighbors, close to the land that feeds us, and in tune with the seasons. And to keep the knowledge of advanced technology alive, but under proper control, in its proper place, and never beyond its limits.

That's what we mean by aboriginality. It's a way of daily life, not a refusal of all knowledge. Like the Ba'ku of Star Trek: Insurrection, a people can understand advanced technology perfectly well, and still choose not to let it run their lives. (See The World They Want to Build.)

Phase One: Stop the Newest

Start with the fields we've only just begun: genetic engineering, synthetic biology, nanotechnology inside the human body, the race to build ever more powerful AI, and the most exotic experiments of high-energy physics.

None of these can be argued to be necessary. We don't depend on them. No one's dinner, water, or warmth relies on microscopic robots in the bloodstream, or on animals redesigned in a laboratory. Because nothing depends on them yet, they're the easiest to stop, and the most dangerous to continue. Every year they advance, more comes to depend on them, and they become harder to unwind. (See Burning the Bridges and The Machine God.)

So the first step is simply to stop.

Phase Two: Put Down the Screen

Then work back to the previous round: the smartphone, social media, and the screen that has crept into every room, every meal, and every child's hands.

This one is personal before it's political. It starts with each of us, and with each family and village, deciding where screens belong and where they don't: not at the table, not in the bedroom, not in the commons, not in the hands of small children. (See The Disembodied Human.)

Phase Three: Rebuild the Bridges

Next comes the long work of restoring what the older layers destroyed, so that we have something to stand on.

  • Replant gardens and orchards close to home, and take up concrete and asphalt where it isn't needed.
  • Clean the rivers and streams, so that water can be drunk from them again.
  • Restore the forests and wetlands, so that there's wild food to gather.
  • Relearn the skills that faded: growing, preserving, building, mending, healing with plants, reading the land and the sky.

These are the bridges we burned. Rebuilding them is what makes every later step safe. (See Burning the Bridges.)

Phase Four: Put Each Layer in Its Place

Once the foundation is solid again, each layer of technology can be moved back to its proper scale, under the Seniority Principle of The Multi-Layered Economy: older, more basic systems must never depend on newer ones.

  • The village lives mostly on foot, by hand, with tools of daily life.
  • The forge and the workshop serve the township.
  • Heavy industry serves the city.
  • The grid serves the metropolis.
  • The computer serves everything below it, and rules nothing.

Each community chooses its own pace, and its own tools, by its own agreement. (See Who Steers?.)

What We Keep

Some technologies are easy to defend. Plumbing and heating can very easily be argued to be necessary. So can the medicine that sets a broken bone or saves a child in an emergency, and the knowledge that keeps a community safe from disease.

The question to ask of every tool is simple. Does it serve Life, or does Life serve it? Does it make us more whole, more connected, and more free, or less? Does anything basic depend on it, and should it?

A tool that serves Life, in its proper place, can stay.

How Long?

This isn't a five-year plan. It's the work of generations. Technolatry took about ten thousand years to weave its web, and the way back won't happen overnight.

But it doesn't have to wait for everyone. It can begin with one person, one family, one garden, and one village, choosing a different direction, and showing the rest of us what's possible. (See Organize Your Village.)