Nature vs. Technolatry

Objections and Answers

What people say, and what we say back.

"Modern medicine saves lives."

It does, and the Earth Party doesn't want to throw it away. A setting for a broken bone, a surgery after a car accident, an antibiotic for a serious infection: these are real gifts.

But most of the diseases we now suffer from are caused by the many ways our lives have become unnatural. Chronic, noncommunicable diseases, such as heart disease, cancer, diabetes, and chronic lung disease, cause about three out of every four deaths worldwide. The World Health Organization names their main risk factors as tobacco, physical inactivity, harmful use of alcohol, unhealthy diets, and air pollution (WHO).

Those are diseases of the way we live. Among people still living as foragers, they're rare. Not absent, but rare. So much of modern medicine is a partial compensation for the harm done by the rest of modern life. (See The Technolatric Dialectic.)

"Children used to die all the time."

That's true, and it shouldn't be softened. Among hunter-gatherers and in most of the premodern world, about half of all children died before reaching adulthood. Today, worldwide, about 4% do (Our World in Data). That's one of the greatest changes in human history.

But three things are worth adding.

First, much of the danger came from earlier technology. Crowded farming villages and cities, living close beside domestic animals and their waste, are where many of the great infectious diseases took hold. Modern medicine partly fixed what earlier technology had made worse.

Second, saving children doesn't justify everything else. The medicine that saves a child's life doesn't require factory farms, social media, or a planet paved with cities. It's possible to keep one without the others.

Third, under the Pyramid, you keep the medicine. Nothing in the Earth Party's plan asks anyone to give up the knowledge that saves children. In a multi-layered society, that knowledge stays alive and available, in its proper place. (See The Pyramid of Technological Emergence and The Multi-Layered Economy.)

"You're typing this on a computer."

Yes. And you're paying taxes, even if you don't want to.

Once systems are set up, we have to work within them. That says nothing about whether we approved of their being set up in the first place. Someone who uses the roads still has every right to wish the gardens hadn't been paved over to build them.

And there's nothing contradictory about using a tool to argue that tools should be kept in their place. That's exactly what we're asking for.

"So you want to go back to the Stone Age?"

No. We want every age to be available.

Under The Multi-Layered Economy, every layer of human industry, from Stone to Digital, stays alive at its own scale, layered one upon the next. Anyone can live as close to the land as they like, and the forge, the mill, the grid, and the computer are still there, serving everything below them. Nothing is lost. Everything is put back in its place.

"Then why don't you go live in a teepee?"

Where? Most of the forests that once fed people have been cut down or emptied of their wildlife. Most of the land is owned, fenced, or paved. The rivers are polluted. The bridge back has been burned. (See Burning the Bridges.)

Rebuilding it is a shared project, not something one person can do alone in the woods. (See A Phased Backtrack to Aboriginality.)

"People live longer now."

On average, yes, mostly because fewer children die. But hunter-gatherers who survive childhood often live into their sixties and seventies (Gurven and Kaplan). The difference in adult lifespan is smaller than most people think.

And length isn't the only measure of a life. How many of our extra years are spent in chronic illness, on medication, or alone? How much of each day is spent working, commuting, or staring at a screen? (See Technology Failed at Its Central Purpose.)

"Hunter-gatherers were violent."

Some were. It would be dishonest to pretend otherwise. At Jebel Sahaba, in Sudan, a cemetery about 13,000 years old holds many people who died violently (Wikipedia). At Nataruk, in Kenya, about 10,000 years ago, a group of people, including a pregnant woman, were killed together (Wikipedia).

Life before civilization wasn't paradise. But neither is life after it. Civilization didn't end violence. It organized it, and gave it bigger weapons. The twentieth century alone saw wars that killed tens of millions. The answer to violence isn't more technology. It's the Law. (See The Law of the Earth.)

"Technology is neutral. It depends on how you use it."

Some tools are close to neutral. A hammer can build a house or break a window. But many technologies carry their own direction. A car spreads a town apart. A smartphone pulls attention away from the people in the room. A factory farm can't be run kindly at scale. The technology shapes the life around it, whatever the intentions of the person using it.

And the question isn't only how a tool is used. It's what it replaces, what it depends on, and what it does to the systems beneath it. (See Another Place for the Chain to Break.)

"Progress is inevitable. You can't stop it."

That's the central tenet of technolatry, and it isn't true. Every technology was chosen by someone. Communities like the Amish have been choosing which tools to accept, and which to refuse, for generations. (See Who Steers? and The Ten Tenets of Technolatry.)

"How will we feed eight billion people without industrial farming?"

That's a serious question, and it deserves a serious answer. Synthetic fertilizer now feeds about half of the world's population (Our World in Data). No one should pull that support away overnight, and the Earth Party has no power to force anyone to.

The answer is gradual, voluntary, and local: rebuilding living soil, growing food close to home, restoring forests and wetlands, and practicing Permaculture, one village at a time, over generations. Each village that learns to feed itself is one less link in the chain.

"You're a Luddite."

The Luddites were skilled workers who saw their crafts, their communities, and their livelihoods destroyed by machines owned by someone else. They weren't against all tools. They were against being made the servants of machinery. We're in good company. (See You're Not the First.)